The Indian government primarily relies on indirect taxes like VAT and CENVAT to generate revenue, streamlining tax collection on goods and services at various stages of production and distribution. Taxes in India are classified broadly into direct and indirect taxes, ensuring that only eligible individuals and entities are responsible for paying them. Before the introduction of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) in 2017, the country had a layered system of indirect taxation.
VAT (Value Added Tax) and CENVAT (Central Value Added Tax) were two major components of this system, and both played a significant role in collecting taxes at various stages of production and distribution of goods and services.
VAT (Value Added Tax) is a type of consumption tax that applies to products at every stage of their supply chain, from production to final sale. The tax is calculated based on the added value at each stage of the product’s life cycle. The government introduced VAT in India on April 1st, 2005, to replace the existing Sales Tax system and unify the country under a single market framework.
CENVAT (Central Value Added Tax) allows manufacturers to utilize central excise and customs credit duty or excise tax or additional duties paid on input materials to offset the excise duty payable on final products. It comes under the central government. CENVAT replaced the earlier system called MODVAT (Modified Value Added Tax).
You may also want to know Section 194I – TDS on Rent
Both VAT and CENVAT tax were extremely critical and contributed to India’s indirect tax system before GST, but they differ in various ways. Below is a breakdown of the significant differences between the two:
| Context of differentiation | CENVAT | VAT |
| Purpose of taxation | Prevent duplication of tax. | Elimination of the cascading taxing effect. |
| Authority of collection | Central Government of India | Respective State governments wherein the transaction take place. |
| Available credit | CENVAT credit | VAT credit |
| Implementing agency | Central Board of Excise and Customs | State Commercial Tax Departments |
| Nature of tax | Excise/Service | Sales |
| Tax rates | Varies based on the raw material used in the process of manufacture | Varies between states and products |
| Applicability | Applicable to the inputs/raw materials used in manufacturing a final product. | Applicable on every value addition to a commodity. |
To better understand the difference between VAT and CENVAT, let’s consider a case involving a manufacturer of cricket bats.
The manufacturer purchases wood (raw material) for ₹2,000, paying 5% VAT, which amounts to ₹100. This becomes the manufacturer’s VAT credit. After producing the cricket bats, the manufacturer sells them for ₹8,000, which attracts 5% VAT, equating to ₹400. However, since the manufacturer has ₹100 VAT credit, the final VAT payable is ₹300 (₹400 – ₹100).
Now, assuming the manufacturer is subject to a 14% excise duty, the excise duty on purchasing the raw material (₹2,000) would be ₹280. On selling the final product for ₹8,000, the excise duty would be ₹1,120. Using the CENVAT credit on the excise duty paid for raw materials, the manufacturer can reduce the final excise duty to ₹840 (₹1,120 – ₹280).
You may also want to know GST on Food and Restaurants
On July 1st, 2017, India introduced the Goods and Services Tax (GST), replacing multiple indirect taxes like VAT and CENVAT with a single unified tax system. GST subsumes all indirect tax levied by the Centre and State, offering a more transparent and straightforward tax regime across the country. The introduction of GST has brought about transparency, neutrality, and parity in the taxation of goods and services.
Before the introduction of GST, VAT and CENVAT were crucial to India’s indirect tax system. While VAT focused on eliminating cascading taxes on value additions across the supply chain, CENVAT was instrumental in providing manufacturers with tax credits on excise duties.
The transition to GST simplified the tax system, combining the functionalities of both VAT and CENVAT into a single tax structure. This shift has provided a uniform taxation process for businesses and consumers alike.
VAT was introduced to prevent the duplication of taxes and eliminate the cascading effect by levying a central sales tax on each value addition during the supply chain process.
CENVAT credit refers to the tax credit that manufacturers can claim on excise duty paid for inputs, allowing them to offset the excise duty payable on the final product.
No, VAT has been replaced by GST since July 1st, 2017, as part of India’s tax reform to simplify the indirect taxation system.
VAT was collected by the authority respective State Government in India, depending on where the transaction occurred.
The main benefit of CENVAT was to eliminate the cascading effect of excise duty, allowing manufacturers to pay excise duty only on the final product rather than at every stage of production.
VAT and CENVAT were replaced by GST (Goods and Service Tax), which consolidated various indirect taxes under one unified tax system.
Get the link to download the App
