What is Herd Mentality in Stock Markets?

In March 2020, Nifty falls 38% in five weeks.

Investors who hadn’t touched their portfolios in years suddenly redeemed everything. Mutual fund units accumulated over a decade, gone in days. Not because the companies they owned had stopped being good businesses. But due to the reason of everyone else was selling, and holding on felt like the one irrational position in a room full of people running for the door.

Six months later, Nifty was back at pre-crash levels. The sellers had crystallised permanent losses. The holders recovered completely.

That’s herd mentality, it’s not stupidity, not a personality flaw but a deeply human psychological response that financial markets are specifically built to amplify, and that costs investors real money in every single market cycle without exception.

With this guide, you will have a broader picture about hard mentality in stock market, why it happens, what it leads to and how to avoid it at the earliest. 

What is Herd Mentality?

Herd mentality in simple terms refers to as – “doing what everyone around you is doing, because everyone around you is doing it, without stopping to check whether it actually makes sense for you.”

In everyday life this is often rational when everyone at a party suddenly runs for the exit, following them without knowing why is smart. There’s probably a reason.

Copying the crowd is survival instinct working correctly. However, financial markets are different territory.

In markets, the crowd is frequently wrong at the exact moments it feels most convincingly right. The more unanimous the crowd, the louder the agreement, the more dangerous the trade usually is. That’s the counterintuitive thing about herd psychology that most investors never fully internalise until they’ve paid for the lesson.

Herd mentality in financial markets is when investors following and copying what other participants are doing, driven by emotion rather than independent analysis, pushing asset prices far beyond what fundamentals can justify.

But what does herd mentality actually do to a portfolio? 

It causes buying when prices are already stretched because buying feels safe when everyone agrees, and selling when prices are depressed because selling feels necessary when everyone is panicking. 

Buy high, and sell low. Repeated every cycle by millions of investors who consider themselves rational people.

What is Herd Psychology in Stock Markets?

Several psychological mechanisms run simultaneously. Worth understanding each one separately.

Social validation

Humans are wired to feel more confident in a decision when others confirm it. Ten colleagues, a popular influencer, and three news channels all saying a stock is going up, buying feels rational. The validation becomes the analysis. The actual business behind the stock becomes an afterthought.

Loss aversion

Losing Rs 10,000 feels roughly twice as painful as gaining Rs 10,000 feels good. That asymmetry means fear of loss during crashes overwhelms the logic of staying invested. When markets fall hard, the emotional arithmetic is dominated by the need to stop the pain, even when selling at that point makes the loss permanent.

FOMO

Fear of missing out, the real FOMO is when the stock doubles. Colleagues mention it at lunch. 

It’s on every financial news channel, and the feeling of having missed something accumulates until buying feels like catching up rather than chasing. The fact that the opportunity already happened that the doubling is already in the price, doesn’t register emotionally the way it registers analytically.

Information cascades

Once enough people make the same decision, new investors assume those people had information or insight that justified it. They follow without verifying. Those followers attract more followers. The original reason for the move, often thin or speculative, gets buried under momentum that looks exactly like confirmation.

Why do markets amplify herd thinking specifically? 

Because price is visible in real time. Every investor can see what everyone else is doing, second by second. That constant visibility creates feedback loops that don’t exist in most other areas of decision-making.

Why Investors Develop Herd Mentality?

Fear of Missing Out (FOMO)

Again this the the major reason – Bull markets breed FOMO faster than almost any other environment.

Stock runs 40% in a month. It’s everywhere. Social media, news, office conversations. The investor who didn’t own it starts calculating what Rs 1 lakh invested at the start of the month would be worth now. The calculation produces regret. Regret produces the impulse to buy now so the same thing doesn’t happen again next month.

Problem: by the time FOMO peaks, the easy money has almost always already been made. The investors experiencing the most intense FOMO are frequently the ones buying closest to the top.

Fear During Market Crashes

Panic selling is herd mentality running in reverse. Same mechanism, opposite direction, same outcome.

Markets fall 10% is unsettling; markets fall 20% is alarming but markets fall 30% with wall-to-wall news coverage of financial collapse. At that point, selling feels like the only rational response.

It’s usually the worst possible response. Timed almost perfectly to lock in maximum losses before the recovery begins.

The investors who panic-sold in March 2020 weren’t irrational people. They were responding to real fear amplified by a crowd that was also responding to real fear. That’s the insidious part about herd psychology, it feels rational from inside it.

Influence of Media and Social Platforms

Financial media runs on attention. Attention comes from urgency, from excitement, from the feeling that something important is happening right now and the viewer needs to act.

Rising stocks get heavy coverage because the coverage attracts viewers, and coverage attracts new investors as well. Additionally, new investor money pushes prices higher because higher prices generate more coverage, and the cycle feeds itself until it doesn’t.

Social media adds retail amplification on top of that with stock tips on WhatsApp groups. Telegram channels with hundreds of thousands of followers calling multibaggers. Then, YouTube thumbnails with lamborghinis next to stock charts. All these creates a direct pipeline from hype to retail buying that didn’t exist in previous market cycles.

Reliance on Experts and Influencers

Nothing wrong with learning from experienced investors. The problem is when following someone else’s analysis replaces doing your own.

Well-known investor mentions a stock positively in an interview. Stock moves 5% that day. 

However, most buyers haven’t read a single page of the company’s annual report. They’ve outsourced analysis entirely to someone whose time horizon, portfolio context, and risk tolerance might be completely different from theirs. That’s not investing. That’s delegation without understanding what you’re delegating or to whom.

Real Examples of Herd Mentality in Stock Markets

Market Bubbles

SME IPO Frenzy 2021 to 2022

Several SME IPOs listed at 100 to 300% premiums. Grey market premiums ran hot for weeks before listing. Retail investors applied in companies they hadn’t analysed, based entirely on the expectation that listing premiums would continue regardless of business quality. Many corrected sharply within months. The herd rushed in on price momentum. Fundamentals were irrelevant to the buying decision, and they became very relevant to the outcome.

Global Tech Bubble 1999 to 2000

Companies with no revenue, no product, sometimes no actual business plan, valued at billions because they had a website and a dot-com suffix. Institutional investors who knew better bought anyway because not participating meant underperforming peers who were participating. Professional fund managers herding to avoid career risk. The crash wiped out trillions globally. Herd behaviour all the way up and down.

Market Crashes

March 2020

Nifty: 12,362 on February 19. Nifty: 7,610 on March 24. 38% fall in 33 trading sessions. Mutual fund redemptions spiked sharply. Systematic investors who had been running SIPs for years suddenly redeemed in panic. By December 2020, Nifty had recovered all losses. By end of 2021: 18,000+. The panic sellers locked in losses and missed the entire recovery. Both things simultaneously.

Trending Stock Rally

PSU Stocks 2023 to 2024

Defence PSUs, railway stocks, power sector companies – ignored for years, suddenly the most talked-about trade in Indian markets. Prices ran 200 to 500% in some names. Retail interest, media coverage, influencer content all amplified the momentum. Late entrants bought at valuations pricing in decades of perfect execution. When the rally cooled, many were sitting on 30 to 50% drawdowns in stocks bought entirely because of the trend.

How Herd Mentality Creates Market Bubbles?

The pattern is not new. Every bubble across history follows roughly this structure. The asset changes. The psychology doesn’t.

Risks of Herd Mentality in Investing

The compounding damage is significant. Buy at the top of a herd-driven rally. Sell at the bottom of the subsequent crash. Getting back to the original position might require a 100% gain from the low. Before transaction costs. Before tax on any short-term gains realised on the way out.

Are There Any Positive Effects of Herd Mentality?

Genuinely, yes. Three real ones.

1. Improved liquidity: When herd buying increases participation, it improves liquidity for everyone. More buyers and sellers means easier execution even for investors doing disciplined research-based investing.
2. Trend formation: Herd behaviour creates sustained trends that technical and momentum investors can exploit, if they’re positioned before the herd arrives rather than with it.
3. Faster price discovery: When significant new information reaches markets, herd reactions accelerate repricing. Earnings surprises, policy changes, macro data, herd behaviour incorporates information into prices quickly, which improves overall market efficiency.

Caveat on all three: these benefits are captured by investors already positioned before the herd arrives. Not by the ones arriving with it.

How to Avoid Herd Mentality While Investing?

Do Your Own Research

Before buying any stock, answer this without anyone else’s opinion: what does this company do, is it profitable, what does it cost relative to earnings, and why do you expect it to be worth more in three to five years?

If the answer is “because everyone is buying it,” that’s not research. That’s herd mentality with an extra step.

Fundamental checklist before buying:

Follow Long-Term Investment Goals

Every portfolio needs a written investment policy, even a simple one. Asset allocation targets. Time horizon. Risk tolerance.

When a herd-driven market move creates the impulse to change something, compare that impulse against the written policy. If the change isn’t justified by the policy, the impulse is probably emotional. Don’t act on it. Sleep on it. Often looks different in the morning.

Diversify Your Portfolio

Diversification reduces the damage from any single herd-driven mistake. One stock or sector collapses after attracting herd buying, the impact on the overall portfolio stays contained.

Avoid Rumours and Social Media Tips

A WhatsApp forward has no accountability. A YouTube stock recommendation has no disclosure of the creator’s position. A Telegram channel promising multibaggers has no regulatory oversight.

Verified: company annual reports, exchange filings on BSE and NSE, SEBI-registered research analysts with disclosed conflicts of interest.

Unverified: everything else.

Stick to Investment Discipline

SIP investors who stopped in March 2020 missed buying Nifty units at 7,600. Investors who kept running bought at some of the lowest prices of the decade. Discipline in downturns is specifically what makes long-term SIP investing work. Stopping during crashes is herd mentality directly interfering with a sound strategy.

Signs You’re Falling Into Herd Mentality

Honest self-check:

• Bought a stock primarily because colleagues or friends were discussing it
• Recent trades based on news headlines rather than company research
• Checked portfolio more than three times yesterday
• Changed asset allocation more than twice in the last six months based on market movements
• Redeemed mutual fund units during a fall and waited to reinvest until recovery
• Applied for an IPO primarily because the grey market premium was high
• Can’t clearly explain what every company you currently own actually does

More than two or three of those: herd mentality is influencing decisions more than you’d like to admit. That’s not unusual. It affects nearly every investor at some point across market cycles. Recognising it is what makes the difference between learning from it and repeating it.

The Bottom Line: What Herd Mentality Actually Costs

Here’s the uncomfortable truth about herd mentality that most financial content skips over.

It doesn’t feel like herd mentality when you’re in it.

Selling in March 2020 didn’t feel like panic. It felt like the only sensible response to a genuinely terrifying situation. Buying PSU stocks in late 2024 at stretched valuations didn’t feel like chasing a trend. It felt like finally recognising an opportunity everyone else had already spotted. The rationalisation is always there. The crowd always has reasons.

That’s what makes herd psychology genuinely difficult to defend against. It’s not that investors don’t know the concept. Most do. It’s that in the moment, the herd’s behaviour feels like it’s based on something real. And sometimes it is. Markets do crash. Trends do run. The problem is that by the time the crowd is unanimous about something, the easy money is usually already made or the damage is already done.

The investors who consistently sidestep herd-driven mistakes aren’t necessarily smarter. They’re more deliberate. They wrote down their investment rationale before buying. They set an asset allocation and stuck to it when the market moved against them. They asked “why am I actually doing this” before acting on a market impulse, and were honest when the answer was “because everyone else seems to be.”

Small habits. Boring, even. But compounded across decades of market cycles, the difference between an investor who consistently acts on independent analysis and one who consistently follows the crowd is enormous.

Not just in returns. In the quality of the investing experience itself. Because the investor who doesn’t need the crowd to validate every decision also doesn’t need to watch financial news every hour, doesn’t feel sick every time the market falls 5%, and doesn’t spend retirement years wondering what the portfolio would have looked like if they’d just held on through the crashes instead of selling at the bottom.

That investor exists. It just takes practice.

Jainam Broking provides equity research tools and market access through one integrated platform. Open a free Demat account in five minutes.